Fixed or variable
Fixed or variable? Decide on your situation, not the headline.
The rate should come last. What you are choosing is how much payment risk you carry, and what you pay to have a lender carry it for you. Look at 7 plain questions, from payment stability to your plans, then compare both on your own numbers, including what it costs to leave early.
Compare fixed and variableor book a call
400+ five-star Google reviews
How it works
Answer the 7 questions
Payment stability, risk, your cushion, your plans, affordability, the rate cycle and your income.
Put numbers on it
Compare both payments, test a higher rate and estimate the penalty to break each one.
Talk it through
We look at your real penalty terms and the lenders that fit, then you decide.
The number almost everyone forgets
When you sign, you also lock in what it costs to leave early, and that differs a lot between the 2. If you might move or refinance before the term ends, the exit cost can matter as much as the rate.
Variable
About 3 months of interest
The usual penalty to break a variable mortgage early.
Fixed, smaller lenders
3 months or an interest rate differential
Often the greater of the 2.
The 7 questions that decide it
No single question decides it. Look at all 7 together. Each one links to a tool that puts a number on it.
1
Payment stability
How much you value a payment that never moves. This is about stress as much as budget.
- Leans fixed: a changing payment would cost you sleep
- Leans variable: a moving payment does not bother you
2
Risk tolerance
How a payment that moves with the Bank of Canada sits with you, month to month.
- Leans fixed: you need the number set for the whole term
- Leans variable: you can live with 18 months of movement
3
Savings and equity cushion
Savings, home equity and access to money if a payment climbs for a while.
- Leans fixed: a thin cushion
- Leans variable: solid savings and equity
4
Plans for the future
Whether you might move, refinance or change course before the term ends. This is where the penalty matters.
- Leans fixed: staying put for the whole term
- Leans variable or a short fixed: a sale or change is likely
5
Affordability over time
Whether you could handle a higher payment for 12 to 24 months, not only at the rate you start with.
- Leans fixed: a lasting increase would strain you
- Leans variable: you could carry an increase for a while
6
Where rates are in the cycle
The general outlook, weighed without pretending anyone can time it.
- Leans fixed: an uncertain or rising outlook
- Leans variable: more cuts widely expected
7
Income and the economy
Steady, predictable income gives you more room. Commission, bonuses or self-employment narrow it.
- Leans fixed: income that changes a lot
- Either can work: steady, predictable income
What happens next
The steps
- Day 1A call about your plans, your budget and how you feel about a moving payment.
- After the callWe compare fixed and variable options side by side, with the penalty terms behind each.
- You chooseWe lock the option you pick and handle the paperwork with the lender.
Documents to have ready
- Your current mortgage statement or renewal letter
- Recent pay stubs, or 2 years of tax returns if self-employed
- Any plans to move, sell or refinance in the next 5 years
Who you work with
- Your brokerLays out both options and the cost of each.
- Your loan specialistGathers documents and keeps it on time.
Tools
Questions people ask
Is fixed or variable better right now?
There is no single right answer. The lower rate on paper is only the better deal if your budget and your nerves can carry the structure that comes with it. Weigh all 7 factors above for your situation, not the rate alone.
What does it cost to break a fixed or a variable mortgage?
Breaking a variable mortgage usually costs about 3 months of interest. Breaking a fixed mortgage is often the greater of 3 months of interest or an interest rate differential, which can run into the thousands at a big bank. Run yours through the penalty calculator before you decide.
Can I switch from variable to fixed later?
Many variable mortgages let you convert to a fixed rate during the term without a penalty, at the fixed rates your lender offers that day. It is a useful backstop, but the rate you move into may be higher than the one you see today.
Does choosing variable mean I am gambling?
No. Variable is a trade: you take on payment movement for a starting rate that is often lower and a smaller penalty to leave. It suits people with steady income and a cushion. If 1 increase would really hurt, fixed buys you peace of mind, and that is a fair thing to buy.
Do I have to pay you?
For most mortgages, no. The lender pays us when your mortgage funds. In a few cases, like private lending, there can be a fee, and we tell you what it is before you commit to anything.
Not sure where to start? Talk it through with us.
Book a call with our team. You'll leave knowing your options and the numbers behind each one.