Buying from a Non-Resident? You Could Owe 25% of the Price to the CRA
What Happens If You Buy a Home From a Non-Resident Seller?
If you buy property in Canada from a non-resident seller, you are required to hold back 25% of the purchase price until the seller gets a tax clearance certificate from the CRA. If you don't, you could be forced to pay the seller's tax bill yourself. A buyer in Toronto learned this the hard way. He bought a condo for $368,000 from a seller who lived in California. At closing, nobody held back any funds. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) later sent the buyer a bill for $92,000, which is exactly 25% of the purchase price. He fought it in tax court and lost. This situation is rare, and most people buying from a local seller will never encounter it. But when it does happen, it's a five or six-figure problem that is entirely preventable if your lawyer takes one simple step before closing.
Key Takeaways
- Buyer's Liability: Under Section 116 of Canada's Income Tax Act, the buyer is responsible for ensuring a non-resident seller's potential capital gains tax is paid.
- The Holdback: If the seller doesn't provide a CRA clearance certificate by closing, the buyer's lawyer must hold back 25% of the gross sale price (or 50% for depreciable property like a rental).
- Reasonable Inquiry: Simply asking a seller where they live isn't enough if there are red flags. You need a sworn statutory declaration of residency to be protected.
- Professional Responsibility: Courts have held real estate lawyers and notaries liable for failing to manage this process correctly, but the ultimate financial risk falls on the buyer.
Why Does the CRA Make the Buyer Responsible?
The CRA makes the buyer responsible for a simple reason: they are the only party guaranteed to still be in the country after the deal closes. When someone sells Canadian real estate, there can be a tax on the capital gain. A seller who lives in Canada files a tax return here, so the CRA can easily find them to collect. But when a seller lives in another country, the money from the sale can leave Canada immediately. Once that happens, the CRA has very little power to chase them for the tax they owe. To prevent this, the Income Tax Act puts the obligation on the one person left behind: the buyer. This rule is outlined in Section 116, as explained by Zinati Kay (2026). It's not about punishing the buyer. It's a practical enforcement mechanism to ensure taxes on Canadian property sales get paid, regardless of where the seller lives.
How the Non-Resident Withholding Process Works
The process involves a few critical steps and deadlines that your lawyer must manage. First, the non-resident seller is supposed to notify the CRA of the sale by filing Form T2062. According to Lamba Law (2026), this must be done no later than 10 days after the closing date. If they're late, the penalty is $25 per day, up to a maximum of $2,500. After reviewing the form and receiving a security payment for the estimated tax, the CRA issues a 'Certificate of Compliance' or clearance certificate. This is the green light. However, getting this certificate can take a long time. In 2026, processing times can range from 8 to 16 weeks or even longer, as noted by Insights CPA (2026). If the seller doesn't have this certificate by the closing date, your lawyer must hold back 25% of the purchase price (or 50% for a rental property). If the certificate still hasn't arrived, the buyer must send those funds to the CRA within 30 days after the end of the month you closed. The scariest part is that there's no time limit for the CRA to come after you. They can assess the buyer at any time.
What 'Reasonable Inquiry' Means in Court
The law gives you a defense if, after 'reasonable inquiry,' you had no reason to believe the seller was a non-resident. But two court cases show that the bar for 'reasonable' is high. In the 2018 case involving the Toronto condo, the buyer, Mr. Kao, did ask the seller where he lived and got a signed statement. The problem was the statement was notarized in California but wasn't a sworn statutory declaration. The court pointed to several red flags: the seller's address for service was in California, the unit had a tenant, and the seller had used the same California address when he bought it. The court said that with flags like those, a basic question wasn't enough, and dismissed the buyer's appeal. In a 2017 B.C. case, Mao v. Li, the seller refused to sign a residency declaration at all. The CRA went after the buyers for $695,000. The court found the notary on the deal liable, stating that without a declaration, the buyer's lawyer should have held back the funds. These cases prove that you can't just take a seller's word for it, especially when their story has holes.
Who Counts as a Non-Resident for Tax Purposes?
Being a non-resident for tax purposes isn't just about your passport or citizenship. It all comes down to your residential ties to Canada. The CRA looks at where your home is, where your spouse or common-law partner lives, and where your dependents live. For example, a Canadian citizen who moves to Dubai or Texas for work, sells their car, moves their family, and rents out their Canadian condo can easily be considered a non-resident, even with a Canadian passport. This is a separate issue from Canada's foreign buyer ban, which restricts who can purchase property. In contrast, a 'snowbird' who spends winters in the U.S. but keeps a home and spouse here in Canada is usually still considered a resident. According to data from Statistics Canada in 2024, non-residents owned a small but significant slice of housing: 2.8% in B.C., 2% in Ontario, and 3.2% in Nova Scotia. While these are ownership stats, not sales stats, it shows that these transactions happen, especially in condo markets popular with investors.
How a Non-Resident Seller Can Delay Your Closing
A non-resident seller can create serious problems for your closing timeline, even when everyone is being honest. The 25% or 50% holdback comes directly out of the seller's proceeds. Your mortgage and down payment don't change; your lender still sends the full approved amount to your lawyer. The trouble is on the seller's side. If the seller has a mortgage that is more than 75% of the home's sale price, a 25% holdback means there isn't enough money left to pay off their lender. On a rental property, a 50% holdback makes this even more likely. A seller in this position can't close the deal unless they get the clearance certificate in time or bring a large amount of their own cash to the table to cover the shortfall. When this happens, closings often get pushed back. This can jeopardize your rate hold, mess up your moving plans, and create a domino effect if your own home sale depends on it.
Did the 2026 Federal Budget Change This Rule?
No, not for individuals. On November 5, 2026, the federal budget proposed a change to the withholding rate, but it only applies to non-resident *companies* that sell Canadian property. For them, the proposed holdback would drop from 25% to 15% on general property and from 50% to 30% on depreciable property, effective January 1, 2027. For a person selling a house or a condo, nothing changes. The holdback remains 25% for a principal residence and 50% for a rental. It's also important to remember that this is just a proposal and not yet law. The 2026 federal budget proposed other changes that could affect your mortgage, but this specific update won't help the average home buyer dealing with an individual seller.
4 Steps to Protect Yourself Before Closing
If you have any concern that your seller might be a non-resident, you and your team need to be proactive. Don't assume your lawyer or realtor has it covered. Here's what you need to do.
- Ask at the Offer Stage: Your realtor should ask the listing agent where the seller lives. If the answer is another country, or if they don't know, you need to get this addressed in writing immediately, not the week before closing.
- Get a Sworn Declaration: Insist on a statutory declaration of residency from the seller. This is a formal document sworn in front of a lawyer, notary, or commissioner of oaths. The buyer in the Toronto case had a notarized statement that wasn't sworn, and it didn't save him.
- Look for Red Flags: An address outside of Canada, a tenant in the unit, or a seller signing documents from another country are all warning signs. A property that has clearly been an investment also warrants extra caution. If you see any of these, tell your lawyer right away. Deciding whether to sell your condo or rent it out has its own tax implications, which can make a seller's residency status more complex.
- Let Your Lawyer Hold Back Funds: If there is any doubt whatsoever, or if the seller cannot provide a sworn declaration, instruct your lawyer to hold back 25% (or 50%) of the purchase price. Don't let anyone talk you out of it. This is your only protection against a massive, unexpected tax bill from the CRA.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Section 116 clearance certificate?
A Section 116 clearance certificate, officially called a Certificate of Compliance, is a document issued by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). It confirms that a non-resident seller has made arrangements to pay any Canadian income tax owing on the sale of their property. When a seller provides this certificate to the buyer before closing, the buyer is relieved of the obligation to withhold 25% or 50% of the purchase price. It's the seller's proof that their tax obligations are being met, protecting the buyer from future liability.
How much is the non-resident withholding tax in Canada?
The withholding amount is not technically a tax, but a security payment for potential taxes owed. For non-depreciable taxable Canadian property, like a personal home or vacant land, the buyer must withhold 25% of the gross selling price. For depreciable property, which includes rental properties where the owner may have claimed capital cost allowance (depreciation), the withholding rate is 50% of the gross selling price. This higher rate accounts for the potential recapture of depreciation in addition to capital gains tax, as confirmed by sources like CloudAcc (2026).
What happens if the seller refuses to provide a residency declaration?
A seller's refusal to sign a statutory declaration of residency is a major red flag. As seen in the B.C. court case Mao v. Li, the courts expect your legal representative to act on this. If a seller refuses, your lawyer's only safe course of action is to assume they are a non-resident and withhold the required 25% or 50% of the purchase price at closing. You should not complete the purchase without this holdback in place, as the refusal to sign eliminates your 'reasonable inquiry' defense and exposes you fully to the seller's tax liability.
Can a Canadian citizen be considered a non-resident seller?
Yes, absolutely. Tax residency is determined by your residential ties with a country, not your citizenship or passport. A Canadian citizen who has moved abroad for work, established a home, and moved their family to another country would likely be considered a non-resident of Canada for tax purposes. The CRA's determination focuses on factors like where you maintain a home, where your spouse and dependents reside, and other social and economic ties. Your passport doesn't protect you or your buyer from Section 116 requirements.
Who is responsible for withholding the tax, the buyer or their lawyer?
The Income Tax Act places the legal responsibility directly on the purchaser (the buyer). However, in practice, the buyer's real estate lawyer or notary is the one who executes the holdback. They manage the trust accounts where funds are held during the transaction. A key part of your lawyer's job is to identify this risk and protect you by either obtaining the clearance certificate, securing a sworn residency declaration, or holding back the required funds. While your lawyer performs the action, the financial liability ultimately rests with you if it's not done correctly.
This isn't a common issue, but when it arises, the stakes are incredibly high. The key is to ask the right questions early and never assume your real estate agent or lawyer has your back without confirming it. If you're considering buying a property and have questions about the seller's residency, we can help you figure out what to ask before you even make an offer.
To see the mortgage rates you could qualify for today, check out our live rates at rate.getflowmortgage.ca. If you have questions about your specific situation, you can email me directly at alex@getflowmortgage.ca or call us at 604-262-3500.
By Alex McFadyen, Mortgage Broker & CEO, Flow Mortgage Co.
What to do next
Run your own numbers in our renewal calculator, or read the mortgage penalty calculator for the full picture. If you want a second set of eyes, book a free call and we'll go through it with you.